“THE STORY OF AGATHA CHRISTIE’S REAL THURSDAY MURDER CLUB”

 

“THE STORY OF AGATHA CHRISTIE’S REAL 

THURSDAY MURDER CLUB”

 

While Richard Osman’s beloved series The Thursday Murder Club is a work of modern fiction, the premise of a group of brilliant minds gathering to dissect unsolved crimes and craft perfect puzzles is rooted firmly in history.

Agatha Christie did not have a covert team of pensioners in a retirement village, but she was the leading figure in a very real, very exclusive, and slightly theatrical group known as The Detection Club.

 

1. The Birth of the Detection Club (1930):

In the late 1920s, the "Golden Age" of detective fiction was in full swing, but the genre was often dismissed by critics as mere mass-market entertainment.

·        The Founder: In 1930, author Anthony Berkeley Cox (who wrote as Anthony Berkeley) invited a group of fellow crime writers to dinner at his home.

·        The Purpose: The goal was to create a professional fellowship to elevate the standards of detective fiction, share technical knowledge, and socialize away from the prying eyes of the public.

·        The Original Members: The roster was a "who’s who" of crime fiction, including Agatha Christie, Dorothy L. Sayers, G.K. Chesterton, and Ronald Knox.

 

2. Covert Sleuthing: Dinner and Discussion:

Unlike the fictional characters in a village, the real Detection Club met in London restaurants. Their meetings were a mix of professional discussion and macabre humor.

Mining True Crime

Members were obsessed with contemporary murder cases. They would bring newspaper clippings of unsolved crimes to dinners, debating the evidence, analyzing the psychology of the suspects, and playing "armchair detective." They often exchanged letters with Scotland Yard detectives to learn about real forensic techniques.

The Rules of the Game

The club established strict guidelines for fair-play detective fiction, ensuring the reader had a genuine chance to solve the mystery along with the protagonist. These included:

·        No supernatural agencies.

·        No undiscovered poisons.

·        No twin brothers unless mentioned earlier.

·        The detective must disclose all clues.

 

3. The Ritual and Theatricality:

The club was famous for its eccentric traditions, which were largely developed by Dorothy L. Sayers.

·        The Initiation: New members had to undergo a humorous initiation ceremony. They were required to swear an oath while placing their hand on a human skull named "Eric."

·        The Oath: The oath included a promise that the member's detective stories would adhere to the rules of fair play and that they would not rely on "supernatural powers" or "secret diaries" to solve their cases.

 

4. Collaborative Fiction: The Club's Stories:

The club didn’t just talk about crime; they wrote it together. They created experimental novels where each chapter was written by a different member, handed over like a baton.

 

Novel	Year	Note
Behind the Screen	1930	A serial mystery broadcast on the BBC.
The Scoop	1931	Inspired by a real-life Fleet Street killing.
The Floating Admiral	1931	Each author wrote their own solution, which was sealed until the end.

 

 

5. Christie’s Role: From Shy Member to President:

Agatha Christie was famously shy and disliked public appearances, but she was a dedicated member of the Detection Club.

·        The Accusation: After publishing The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, some club members argued she had broken the "fair play" rules with her unreliable narrator. Christie defended her work, and the controversy helped solidify the club's debates on what constituted "fair" mystery writing.

·        The Presidency: Christie became the longest-serving president of the club, serving from 1957 until her death in 1976.

 

6. The Legacy:

The real Detection Club still exists today, meeting three times a year in London. While they no longer strictly enforce the "skull and oath" ritual for every meeting, it remains a prestigious fellowship for crime writers.

While Richard Osman's Thursday Murder Club is purely fictional, it perfectly captures the spirit of camaraderie, intellectual challenge, and fascination with the dark side of human nature that defined Agatha Christie's real-life society of sleuths.

***************************